So let’s get this sorted out right off the bat. This is not a traditional key lime pie. You won’t find sweetened condensed milk or graham crackers in this recipe. But you will find a lusciously lovely lime cream pie that’s a pretty decent replacement. It’s also a no bake key lime pie recipe, so bonus!
This pie is nut free, low carb, and gluten-free to boot. So not bad, all things considered.
Actually, if you like tart and creamy this recipe is pretty dreamy. And although the filling is no bake, you do need to bake up the pie crust.
A creamy easy key lime pie recipe
This no bake key lime pie recipe is sweet but tart. It’s actually a really nice balance between the two and won’t make your lips pucker.
The texture of this pie changes dramatically when allowed to cool. The filling firms up quite nicely and cuts into clean neat pieces.
It’s a great little pie to make in a jiffy. It’s also a wonderful dessert to finish off a spicy meal.
A bit about The lime Juice
Ok, so key limes are the best limes to use in this recipe. I could not get my hands on key limes. I live in the middle of the prairies and a few hours outside of the city. Finding key limes is a bit of a treasure hunt where I am. They do make the difference in this key lime pie recipe though, so if you can get your hands on some, I highly recommend it. The key limes tend to be a bit less bitter and touch more sweet.
I happened to find a big bag of beautiful fresh limes at the market, so I decided to make my pie with them instead. I’ve made this pie dozens of times over the years and although I do like it better with key limes, regular limes work perfectly fine in this recipe, so if that is all you can get, use them!
Please don’t use bottled lime juice. That stuff is bitter and sour, and will ruin your pie. This is a recipe that does much better with fresh ingredients.
A bit about the key lime pie crust
So I went with a coconut crust for this recipe. Since coconut is a natural partner with limes I thought it was a good fit.
The difference with this particular crust recipe is the cinnamon. I loaded a bit of cinnamon in the crust to mimic a traditional graham cracker crust.
This crust bakes up golden, holds its shape very well and does not get soggy when filled. It’s a very good all around, all-purpose crust.
Also no need to roll and cool this crust you can simply press it into the pan and it’s ready to go into the oven.
But, I have found this crust sometimes sticks, so it’s a good idea to either line the bottom of your pan with some parchment (works like a charm), or grease your pan a bit before adding the crust.
A bit about no bake key lime pie filling
This filling is no bake and uses only four ingredients. When the pie crust comes out of the oven to cool, you can start the filling. It only takes a few minutes to whip up.
You could pull together the crust and make the filling in less than 30 minutes. It’s a great little pie to whip up on short notice.
The trick to getting the filling to whip up thick and creamy is to use cold cream cheese and very cold whip cream.
You could also skip the crust all together if you want and turn this into a crustless no-bake pie. It’s pretty damn tasty on all it’s own.
Oh, and I cheated a little and added two drops of green food dye to perk my pie up for photos.
What sweeteners are the best to use in this key lime pie recipe?
~This post may contain affiliate links. If you click one and make a purchase, I may receive a commission at no additional cost to you.
I only ever recommend what ingredient or tools I use for my recipes. You can read more about our disclosure policy here ~
Use your favorite 1:1 sugar substitute.
Powered is preferred over granular, as it blends better and has a nicer texture. Erythritol and xylitol also tend to get grainy when cold, but I found the powdered versions to do it much less.
If you don’t have powdered erythritol or xylitol and only have granular, go ahead and give it a blast with a high-speed blender, or food processor. My favorite powdered sweetener by far is So Nourished Monk Fruit Blend, I find it has almost no aftertaste at all.
Swerve and stevia will work perfectly fine here as well as does any powdered erythritol or xylitol brand.
Just remember, xylitol is poisonous to dogs and cats, so if that’s your choice and you have little furry friends running around, be aware that it can be deadly for them.
Storage and Serving Suggestions
You can make this no bake key lime pie recipe a day in advance, it does need to cool and firm up for a few hours or overnight.
I added a bit of fresh whip cream and some toasted coconut to the top to pretty it up a bit, entirely optional.
This one will stay fresh in the fridge for daaaaaays. I had one kicking around for five whole days and it was still as good as it was on day one. Make sure to keep it covered and refrigerated.
Got a thing for pies, tarts?
If you like pies and tarts but don’t like carbs and sugar you might enjoy these posts:
How about a pretty lemon tart perfect for a Sunday brunch.
Or these small french fruit tarts with a creamy vanilla custard.
Or this show stopping no bake strawberry pie, perfect for a summer picnic.
Check the batter for flavour before pouring into the pie crust . Limes can vary in tartness, so you may need to add more or less sweetener to off set the sour. Since the batter has no eggs, you're safe to taste it! As an Amazon Associate and member of other affiliate programs, I earn from qualifying purchases.
Lime Pie Filling
Lime Pie Filling
Nutrition Information: Yield: 12 Serving Size: 1
Amount Per Serving: Calories: 478 Total Fat: 46.8g Saturated Fat: 28g Trans Fat: 1g Unsaturated Fat: 14g Cholesterol: 175mg Sodium: 168mg Carbohydrates: 9.6g Fiber: 3.6g Sugar: 3.9g Protein: 7g
Check the batter for flavour before pouring into the pie crust . Limes can vary in tartness, so you may need to add more or less sweetener to off set the sour. Since the batter has no eggs, you're safe to taste it!
As an Amazon Associate and member of other affiliate programs, I earn from qualifying purchases.